Option Calming Wave Machine sensory bottle (oil, water and fun things) Option water, glue, glitter, food coloring. Option toothpicks/skewers and uncooked grain (rice or barley) for a rain maker. Worked well but Toddler wasn't interested.
Simple and effective. Paper plates are a must! Sparkly Paper Plate Angel - for Sunday School I'd let the kids paint glue around edge and then sprinkle clear glitter or silver. Add a ribbon to hang. Write Bible verse on plate?